When it comes to sourcing the best eyeshadow palettes, there are several things to keep in mind. Formula, finish, pigment, blendability, shade range, and colour scheme are all things to take into consideration – and since we’re just as beauty obsessed as you are, we get it. We know what you’re into. And that’s exactly what inspired us to create our own range of By BEAUTY BAY eyeshadow palettes.
We’ve gone above and beyond to create the best eyeshadow palettes you can find, featuring a full spectrum of palette colour stories, from need-to-have neutrals, to bold and brilliant, blues, greens, and reds. Each palette has options for crafting multiple looks, whatever your vibe. And the formula options really are unbelievably endless. Whether it’s a foil-like shimmer, a buttery velvet matte, or the prettiest pearlescent powders – all By BEAUTY BAY eyeshadows are packed with a punch of pigment. They’re long-lasting, affordable, pigmented, and will definitely inspire the makeup artist in you.
If you’re considering adding a By BEAUTY BAY eyeshadow palette to your next haul, it’s always worth checking out the reviews to figure out which palette will be best for you. And since there are thousands of five star reviews for our palettes, we’ve done the hard work for you and rounded them up below. Scroll down to find the best By BEAUTY BAY eyeshadow palette (or palettes) for you.
1. NEUTRAL 42 COLOUR PALETTE
‘Such a nice palette’
Can we talk about how good beauty bays palette are for the price? They’re large sleek design is so handy and I have like 5 of them and that’s it I literally don’t need anything else but those palettes, I love them so much and I cannot wait to get more!
Maria C.
‘Neutral dream!’
This palette has any neutral color that you could imagine…and also has great pigment and super blendable. Would recommend.
Jaimie A.
‘Another perfect pallette’
I love this pallette, beauty bay make the best eye pallettes
Nicole F.
2. FIERY 2.0 16 COLOUR PALETTE
‘Great colors’
This is going to be my go to travel palette. The colors are amazing and easy to blend. I can create any look with this one palette. I think I might “need” the larger version.
Lonni F.
‘Very pigmented & colours look richer in person’
I was surprised by the size of this when it was delivered. This is great value for your money. Very pigmented & lovely neutral colours with a bit of spice and glitter. I am happy about this purchase.
Mercy B.
‘Go-to palette’
Perfect palette for a variety of looks regardless of the season. Great colours and lasting power.
Vicky.
3. MIDNIGHT 16 COLOUR PALETTE
‘Absolutely gorgeous’
The color story is outstanding! Perfect balance of Matte and shimmer shades, blendable and highly pigmented. Always happy with BB palettes!!
Cristina C.
‘YES’
Absolutely love the colour pay-off of these shadows! And so affordable too!!
Molly B.
‘Beautiful’
I love love love love love love, the colours are beautiful! The glitter is gorgeous, it can be built up nicely. If you are obsessed with blues – like me, by all means – go for it!!
Daberechi U.
4. EARTHY 42 COLOUR PALETTE
‘This was my 1st order’
This was my 1st order from beauty bay and WOW these products are amazing the eyeshadow is so pretty I got so many compliments on my eyes and the highlighter was blinding so pretty can’t wait to order again soon!
Taylor D.
‘Amazing palette’
The colours were so pigments. I really wanted to broaden the range of green shades I have and this palette was exactly what I was looking for. Would definitely recommend this to anyone who wants to try and break away from a more neutral look!
Jessica M.
‘Really pretty’
Love the colours, the pigmentation is strong and the sparkly shades are so pretty. The colours compliment each other well. I honestly wish some of these would be available in singles because they’re beautiful and I could see myself running out of them first!
Emily.
5. BRIGHT 2.0 42 COLOUR PALETTE
‘Best rainbow palette’
The formula is amazing!!
The foiled metallics are better than indie shadows and at a fraction of the price
The teal and gold metallics are jaw dropping.
Also some of the best yellow shades I have ever used, they’re pigmented and not dusty or dry.
I wish I’d picked this up ages ago, it’s an absolute gem
Katherine G.
‘Another hit’
Beauty Bays eyeshadow pallets are pretty much my staple go to these days. This one is so good, some highly unique colours here and a great mix of shimmers and mattes. Goes on smooth and blend like a dream, the pigment is intense and they last all day even on hooded eyes.
Ruth J.
6. BERRIES 42 COLOUR PALETTE
‘Literally 10/10 love this palette’
Literally 10/10 love this palette so much, vibrant and pigmented and the glitters apply so beautifully with your fingers!
Mariyah C.
‘Insane pigment!’
The amount of pigment in these eyeshadows is insane! In some other products the only way to really pack colour is to use your finger, but with these eyeshadows even a blending brush will do the trick. The shimmers are also glittery enough, and their colours still come trough nicely. This (and the palettes in other colours) is my new everyday go-to eyeshadow palette!
Miika L.
‘Amazing’
I love the colors, there’s little to no fallout , 10/10!
Aleksandra B.
7. NUDE 42 COLOUR PALETTE
‘AMAZING The best by far!’
There is such a variety of colour so endless possibilities and they are so pigmented and beautiful so happy I bought them will definitely buy again
Sophie A.
‘Perfect addition to my kit’
The wide range of nude colours makes it an immediate add to my kit. There are shades to compliment all skin colours. They blend like a dream and are super pigmented!
Jodie S.
‘Love love love’
Obsessed with this palette – perfect for dance show makeup with all the golds but also great for everyday with the lighter nudes 10/10 would purchase again!
Arrived in good time and exactly as pictured
Isabelle H.
8. TROPICAL 9 COLOUR PALETTE
‘Ahhhhhh!!!’
The pigment is amazing and vibrant, I barely needed to touch my brush to the palet to pick up anything and it goes on the skin amazingly. And the blending! The BLENDING!! I don’t think I’ll buy from any other company ever again.
Dayna B.
‘Gorgeous colours’
This is a beautiful palette with smooth blend able mattes and foily shimmers. I would highly recommend this palette
Penny J.
‘Another amazing palette added to’
Another amazing palette added to my Beauty Bay collection – these colours are so gorgeous, blend beautifully and are super pigmented! Beauty Bay make the best affordable palettes!
Bella H.
9. EARTHY 16 COLOUR PALETTE
‘Amazing’
Everyone comments on my eyes
Mina S.
‘Very pleased’
colours all seemed to be pigmented and high quality. Would repurchase more from the brand especially for the price was impressed.
Sama H.
‘Perfect green palette’
Love this palette. Has a good range of light to deep shades and I love that it has a mix of cool tones and grungy greens.
Lauren.
10. PASTELS PRESSED PIGMENT PALETTE
‘Pride’
Bought this palette for pride so pretty it was perfect. colors are even better in person! would recommend for any look.
Kimberly J.
‘Such a lovely palette’
Really pretty colours that are pretty easy to work with and can be blended. I have created lots of nice looks with this set and the 42 colour bright matte palette which compliments this pastel palette.
Viola G.
‘So many delightful spring colour pigment pallete’
It was so much fun watching my granddaughter practising her make up techniques and using the app to help guide her through the ideas with fabulous results.
Sylvia W.
11. NEUTRAL 16 COLOUR PALETTE
‘LOVE’
Such a gorgeous glam palette. Perfect for weddings and so good for travel as well with the mirror!!
Molly B.
‘Beautiful neutral shades!’
Perfect neutral browns for everyday or you can layer up and add dimension for an evening look. Just what I needed after using up my last morphe pallette!
Sadaf I.
‘Perfect’
Even more beautiful in real than in the photo, super pigmented, easy to use, you can do daily makeup like party makeup with it. If you can take only one palette with you when traveling, take this one
Clara M.
12. THE GOLDEN AGE PALETTE
‘Eyeshadow Pallette’
Such great value, the colours are wonderful and they go on and blend perfectly.
Grainne C.
‘Golden Age Review’
Colours are stunning, perfect for natural looks. Lots of pigment, blends seamlessly. The darker colours are excellent to smoke out your makeup or to just add a little depth. Very versatile, can be used to create a natural or full glam look.
Anna H.
‘Stunning Shades’
Such beautiful shimmer shades and the combination of shimmers and mattes makes it suitable for on the go eye looks
Batool M.
13. BRIGHT MATTE 9 COLOUR PALETTE
‘Rainbow!’
Love this rainbow all matte palette. Super pigmented and blendable. Perfect for a rainbow makeup
Antonella M.
‘Woooow it is great’
The colors are really beautiful and clear. I liked it. It is soft and shiny. I want to repeat the order again. Thank you, Beautybay
Rawan M.
‘super pigmented’
great deal and super pigmented. quality shocked me for the price
Yammy.
14. BERRIES 16 COLOUR PALETTE
‘Everything was super pigmented’
The eye paints have beautiful vibrant colours, are easy to blend and can be layered.
I also loved the berry eye shadow palette, way more than I thought, I use the glittery colours almost every day!
Antonia G.
‘beauty bay 16 pan berries palette’
i was surprised by the beauty bay shadows. they are very pigmented, very easy to blend. the shimmers are very shiny and reflective. i like the formula and i already ordered more BB palettes. you get a lot of product for the money spent.
URSKA P.
‘gorgeous shades and intense pigmentation’
bringing this with me on all my music festivals! soooo cute
Pereni S.
15. NUDE MATTE 9 COLOUR PALETTE
‘Blends really well and is so versatile!’
Such an amazing pallet, has everything i need for a day to day subtle eye or if you want to great a more dramatic look tis palette has it all! also the size of the palette is perfect to just pop into your handbag! the quality of the shadows is fantastic, no fallout and they blend so well! i would definitely recommend 🙂
Lyndsay C.
‘Beautiful palette’
This is the perfect warm toned neutral palette. Perfect size for travelling and a great price also! They blend easily into each other without going patchy and very pigmented.
Sophie P.
‘MY GO-TO PALETTE!’
my favorite palette omg, I’ve been using it since I got it like 4 times now!
Yolibeth.
16. RICH 42 COLOUR PALETTE
‘A makeup staple palette or make a statement palette’
Loveeeeee this palette, not been let down by a single shade- they’re so pigmented and blend like a dream omg. The colours look insane on my darker skin tone n help me serve looks all day every day – full glam or nah i always get flooded with compliments when i use this + these eyeshadows are always the last men standing after a night out so slay xx
Gooby. H.
‘Love it!’
Used this every day since I bought it and so impressed with the formula and the shades are perfect!!
Hannah
‘Rich 42 Colour Palette’
Absolutely stunning 😍
Carrianne A.
